Used Compact SUV Comparison
The two best-selling compact SUVs of the last decade are also the two most cross-shopped used ones, and for a Connecticut or Western Massachusetts buyer the choice comes down to year, drivetrain and budget: the RAV4 has offered an AWD-standard hybrid since 2016 and carries a 10-year battery warranty on 2020 and newer, while the CR-V has the bigger cargo hold and the roomier back seat and generally costs less for the same model year. Here is how they really stack up, generation by generation, from a dealer that sells one and buys both.
Toyota
Used RAV4
Typical used price: about $15,000–$38,300 (2016–2024, national)
4th gen 2013–2018 · 5th gen 2019–2025 · hybrid since 2016, AWD standard on every hybrid · plug-in Prime 2021–2025
Honda
Used CR-V
Typical used price: about $13,550–$31,600 (2016–2023, national)
4th gen 2012–2016 · 5th gen 2017–2022 · 6th gen 2023– · hybrid since 2020 · AWD available on every trim, every year

Our pick is the used RAV4, and for a Connecticut or Western Massachusetts buyer it is not a coin flip. Every 2016 to 2025 RAV4 Hybrid is all-wheel drive, the 2019 and newer ones rate about 40 mpg, from the 2020 model year the battery carries a 10-year/150,000-mile warranty that transfers to you, Toyota Safety Sense has been standard on every trim since 2017, and the gas models pair a non-turbo 2.5 with a conventional automatic in every year. The CR-V earns real wins and we list them plainly: about 2 cubic feet more cargo, 3 inches more rear legroom, CarPlay two years earlier, and about $1,500 to $3,000 less for the same model year and trim nationally. If the most room for the money is the whole job, buy the CR-V. If you want the compact SUV that asks the least of its second and third owners, buy the RAV4. Under $20,000, a 2017 to 2019 RAV4 is the sweet spot.
On value kept, the two split: Kelley Blue Book’s 2026 Best Resale Value Award for compact SUVs went to the CR-V, while Toyota won the brand award and iSeeCars measured the RAV4 among the ten slowest-depreciating vehicles sold. Consumer Reports ranks Toyota first for brand reliability, Honda fourth.
Where the Used RAV4 wins
Categories won
Where the Used CR-V wins
Too close to call: Resale & Brand Reliability
Head-to-Head
| Specification | Used Toyota RAV4 | Used Honda CR-V | Winner |
|---|---|---|---|
| Generations Covered | 4th gen 2013–2018; 5th gen 2019–2025 (2026 is all-new and all-hybrid) | 4th gen 2012–2016; 5th gen 2017–2022; 6th gen 2023–present | Tie |
| Typical Price, 3-Year-Old (2023) | About $27,800–$33,400 (national listings, Oct 2026) | About $24,800 (LX) to $31,600 (Sport Touring Hybrid); EX-L about $27,900 (KBB, Oct 2026) | CR-V |
| Typical Price, 6-Year-Old (2020) | About $20,600 (LE) to $28,200 (Hybrid Limited); gas XLE about $22,900, Hybrid LE about $24,700 (KBB, Oct 2026) | About $18,800 (LX) to $23,000 (Touring); Hybrid LX about $21,400 to Hybrid Touring about $24,300 (KBB, Oct 2026) | CR-V |
| Typical Price, 10-Year-Old (2016) | About $15,000 (LE/SE) to $19,500 (Hybrid Limited) (KBB, Oct 2026) | About $13,550 (LX) to $15,850 (Touring) (KBB, Oct 2026) | CR-V |
| Engines / Transmissions by Generation | 2013–2018: 2.5L four, 176 hp, 6-speed automatic. 2019–2025: 2.5L four, 203 hp, 8-speed automatic. No turbo, no CVT on any year | 2012–2014: 2.4L four, 185 hp, 5-speed automatic. 2015–2016: 2.4L, 185 hp, CVT. 2017–2019: 2.4L (LX, 184 hp) or 1.5L turbo (EX and up, 190 hp), CVT. 2020–present: 1.5L turbo, 190 hp, CVT on every gas trim | RAV4 |
| Hybrid Availability by Year | 2016–2018 (194 hp, 33 mpg); 2019–2025 (219 hp, about 40 mpg); AWD standard on every hybrid year | 2020–2022 (212 hp, 38 mpg, AWD); 2023–present (204 hp, 40 mpg FWD / 37 mpg AWD, Sport trims only) | RAV4 |
| Plug-in Hybrid Available | RAV4 Prime 2021–2024 and Plug-in Hybrid 2025: 302 hp, 42 miles electric, AWD | None in any year | RAV4 |
| EPA Combined MPG, Gas, by Generation | 4th gen: 26 mpg FWD / 25 AWD. 5th gen: about 30 mpg (26 city / 35 highway) | 2012–2014: 26 mpg FWD. 2015–2016: 29 mpg. 5th gen 1.5T: 30 mpg FWD / 29 AWD (2.4L LX: 28). 6th gen: 30 mpg FWD / 29 AWD | Tie |
| EPA Combined MPG, Best Hybrid | About 40 mpg (2019–2025 Hybrid, AWD); Prime 38 mpg after its 42 electric miles | 38 mpg (2020–2022, AWD); 40 mpg FWD or 37 mpg AWD (2023–present) | RAV4 |
| All-Wheel Drive | Available on every gas year; standard on every hybrid 2016–2025 (electric rear motor); torque-vectoring AWD with rear-axle disconnect on Adventure, TRD Off-Road and AWD Limited from 2019 | Real Time AWD available on every trim, every year; standard on the 2020–2022 Hybrid; $1,500 option on most 2023+ trims, standard on Sport Touring | RAV4 |
| Cargo Behind Rear Seat / Rear Legroom (newest used generation) | 37.6 cu ft / 37.8 in (2019–2025) | 39.3 cu ft / 41.0 in (2023–present); 39.2 cu ft / 40.4 in (2017–2022 gas) | CR-V |
| Standard Driver-Assist Suite by Year | Toyota Safety Sense P standard on every trim from 2017; TSS 2.0 from 2019 (adds lane tracing, full-speed adaptive cruise); TSS 2.5 from 2023 | Honda Sensing on the Touring from 2015; standard on EX and up from 2017; standard on every trim from 2020 | RAV4 |
| Apple CarPlay From Model Year | 2019 (every trim); Android Auto from 2020; wireless from 2023 | 2017 (EX and up); every trim from 2023; wireless on EX-L and Sport Touring from 2023 | CR-V |
| Hybrid Battery Warranty (transfers) | 10 yr / 150,000 mi on 2020 and newer; 8 yr / 100,000 mi on 2016–2019; both follow the car to every owner | 8 yr / 100,000 mi; confirm the term on the VIN with a Honda dealer | RAV4 |
| Powertrain Warranty Left on a 3-Year-Old (2023) | 5 yr / 60,000 mi from first sale: about 2 years or until 60,000 miles | 5 yr / 60,000 mi from first sale: about 2 years or until 60,000 miles | Tie |
| Longevity Evidence (iSeeCars 2025 Longest-Lasting SUVs) | RAV4 Hybrid 7.9% chance of 250,000 miles (1.8x the SUV average); RAV4 7.3% (1.7x) | CR-V 10.6% chance of 250,000 miles (2.5x the SUV average), 10th of 21 SUVs | CR-V |
| Towing | 1,500 lb most gas trims; 1,750 lb Hybrid; 3,500 lb Adventure and TRD Off-Road (2018–2024) | Up to 1,500 lb (gas); 1,000 lb Hybrid (2023–present) | RAV4 |
| What $20,000 Buys (national, Oct 2026) | A 2019 RAV4 LE (about $19,300): first year of the 5th gen, 203 hp, 8-speed, TSS 2.0, CarPlay; or a 2017–2018 XLE (about $16,750) with TSS-P | A 2019 CR-V EX (about $18,950) or EX-L (about $20,300): 1.5T, Honda Sensing, CarPlay, sunroof; or a 2020 LX (about $18,800) | Tie |
| Resale Value (KBB 2026 Best Resale Value Awards) | Toyota is the 2026 Best Resale Value Brand; RAV4 (incl. Hybrid) 25.2% five-year depreciation, 7th-lowest of all vehicles (iSeeCars, Mar 2026) | Best Resale Value: Compact SUV; not in iSeeCars’ ten lowest-depreciation vehicles | Tie |
| Brand Reliability (Consumer Reports, Dec 2025) | Toyota 1st, score 66 | Honda 4th, score 59 | RAV4 |
| Hybrid Track Record | RAV4 Hybrid every year since 2016; Toyota hybrids since 1997, about 30 million sold worldwide through 2025 | CR-V Hybrid since 2020; Honda’s two-motor system since 2014 | RAV4 |
Specs reflect manufacturer and EPA figures for the model years shown, checked in November 2026, and vary by trim, drivetrain and condition. Used prices are Kelley Blue Book Fair Purchase Price national averages as of October 2026 (iSeeCars national listing ranges where marked “listings”) and move with the market; prices in Connecticut and Massachusetts tend to run a little above national for AWD and hybrid models. Competitor figures are shown for comparison and are subject to change; confirm current details with the manufacturer. Current Gale used pricing is on each vehicle page, written out the door with the $649 documentation fee included. Contact Gale Toyota for current pricing and availability.
Category by Category
Winner: CR-V
Year for year, the CR-V costs less. On Kelley Blue Book national averages from October 2026, a 2020 CR-V LX runs about $18,800 against about $20,600 for a 2020 RAV4 LE; a 2016 CR-V LX about $13,550 against about $15,000 for a 2016 RAV4 Hybrid to hybrid the gap narrows (2020 CR-V Hybrid EX about $22,200, 2020 RAV4 Hybrid LE about $24,700), but the RAV4’s price includes the 10-year battery warranty. On a fixed budget, the CR-V usually buys one trim up.
Winner: RAV4
Gas to gas these are even: about 30 mpg combined for a 2019 to 2025 RAV4 and 30 for a 1.5-turbo CR-V. The hybrids decide it. Toyota has sold a RAV4 Hybrid since 2016, and every 2019 to 2025 RAV4 Hybrid is rated about 40 mpg with AWD standard. The 2020 to 2022 CR-V Hybrid is rated 38; the 2023 and newer reaches 40 only with front-wheel drive and 37 with AWD. Only the RAV4 offers a plug-in: the 2021 to 2025 Prime runs 42 miles on electricity, then 38 mpg.
Winner: CR-V
This is the CR-V’s clear win. A 2017 to 2022 CR-V holds 39.2 cubic feet behind the rear seat (75.8 folded) with 40.4 inches of rear legroom; the 2023 and newer grows to 39.3 and 41.0. A 2019 to 2025 RAV4 holds 37.6 cubic feet with 37.8 inches of legroom. One note for hybrid shoppers: the 2020 to 2022 CR-V Hybrid gives up cargo space to its battery, at 33.2 cubic feet, while the RAV4 Hybrid keeps the full 37.6.
Winner: RAV4
Both offer AWD on every trim and every year here, and both are fine on a plowed road with good tires. The RAV4 goes further: every RAV4 Hybrid since 2016 is AWD, so there is no front-drive hybrid to screen out of a listing, and from 2019 the Adventure, TRD Off-Road and AWD Limited add torque-vectoring AWD, the TRD on severe-snow-rated all-terrain tires. Think twice about a front-drive gas version of either if your street is plowed last. Our RAV4 snow guide explains the systems.
Winner: RAV4
On gas models the two match: 3 years/36,000 basic and 5 years/60,000 powertrain from the first sale, and both follow the car. The hybrids separate them. Toyota covers the battery on every 2020 and newer RAV4 Hybrid and Prime for 10 years/150,000 miles, “first ownership and all subsequent owners,” wherever it is registered; 2016 to 2019 hybrids get 8 years/100,000. Honda’s term is 8 years/100,000; have a Honda dealer confirm it on the VIN. Details: our Toyota warranty guide.
Winner: RAV4
The positive evidence gives each one something. In iSeeCars’ 2025 Longest-Lasting SUVs study the CR-V has a 10.6 percent chance of reaching 250,000 miles, 2.5 times the SUV average, with the RAV4 Hybrid at 7.9 and the RAV4 at 7.3, both above average. The RAV4 wins on what a second owner can count on: one non-turbo 2.5 and one eight-speed for all seven fifth-generation years, a timing chain on every engine since 2006, Toyota Safety Sense on every trim since 2017, and the longest hybrid battery coverage in the class on 2020 and newer. Either is a 200,000-mile SUV with its maintenance done; the RAV4 gets there with fewer variables.
Winner: Too Close to Call
Each takes a piece. Kelley Blue Book’s 2026 Best Resale Value Awards (March 2026) named the CR-V the compact SUV expected to retain the most value after five years, while Toyota won the Best Resale Value Brand award at about 53 percent of sticker retained, and iSeeCars’ March 2026 study measured 25.2 percent five-year depreciation for the RAV4 including the hybrid, seventh-lowest of any vehicle, with the CR-V outside the top ten. Consumer Reports’ survey published in December 2025 ranks Toyota first for brand reliability at 66 and Honda fourth at 59. On hybrid track record the RAV4 has the longer one: a hybrid every year since 2016 on a system Toyota has sold since the 1997 Prius, about 30 million worldwide through 2025; the CR-V Hybrid arrived for 2020. For a used buyer, strong resale cuts both ways: it is why a same-year RAV4 costs more today and why it should be worth more when you sell.
Common Questions
Both have strong records, and the best positive evidence is close. In iSeeCars’ 2025 Longest-Lasting SUVs study the CR-V has a 10.6 percent chance of reaching 250,000 miles, 2.5 times the SUV average; the RAV4 Hybrid scores 7.9 percent and the gas RAV4 7.3, both well above average. The RAV4 counters with a longer hybrid battery warranty on 2020 and newer (10 years/150,000 miles) and a fifth generation that used one non-turbo 2.5-liter engine and one eight-speed automatic for seven straight years. On any specific car, records matter more than the badge. Open recalls on any VIN are listed at toyota.com/recall; ask us and we will confirm anything open was completed before the car reaches the front line. For a Honda, the same VIN look-up is on Honda’s owner site (owners.honda.com, under Recalls).
The CR-V, for the same model year and trim, by about $1,500 to $3,000 on national averages. Kelley Blue Book Fair Purchase Prices from October 2026 put a 2020 CR-V LX at about $18,800 and a 2020 RAV4 LE at about $20,600; a 2016 CR-V LX at about $13,550 and a 2016 RAV4 LE at about $15,000; a 2023 CR-V LX at about $24,800 while 2023 RAV4 listings start near $27,800. Hybrids are closer: a 2020 CR-V Hybrid EX is about $22,200 against about $24,700 for a 2020 RAV4 Hybrid LE. In Connecticut and Massachusetts both run a little above national because AWD and hybrids are in demand here. Current Gale used pricing is on each vehicle page, written out the door with the $649 documentation fee included.
For the RAV4, 2020 is the sweet spot: the second year of the fifth generation, with Toyota Safety Sense 2.0, Apple CarPlay and Android Auto, the TRD Off-Road option and, on the hybrid, the first year of the 10-year/150,000-mile battery warranty, at about $20,600 for a gas LE and $24,700 for a Hybrid LE nationally. Under $20,000, a 2017 or 2018 RAV4 with Toyota Safety Sense P (about $16,350 to $16,750) is the value. For the CR-V, 2020 to 2022 is the equivalent spot: Honda Sensing on every trim, the 1.5 turbo on every gas trim and the first hybrid, at about $18,800 for a 2020 LX. Under $20,000, a 2019 CR-V EX (about $18,950) with Honda Sensing and CarPlay is the one to find. Any of these bought from a Connecticut dealer carries the state’s 60-day/3,000-mile warranty under Public Act 26-100, which covers every used vehicle under 10 years old; see our Connecticut buying guide and our guide for Massachusetts residents buying in Connecticut.
On gas engines they are even: a 2019 to 2025 RAV4 is EPA-rated about 30 mpg combined, and a 2017 and newer CR-V with the 1.5 turbo is rated 30 mpg front-drive or 29 with AWD (the 2.4-liter CR-V LX of 2017 to 2019 is 28; 2015 and 2016 CR-Vs are 29). Older fourth-generation RAV4s (2013 to 2018) and 2012 to 2014 CR-Vs are both about 26. On hybrids the RAV4 leads: about 40 mpg combined with AWD on every 2019 to 2025 RAV4 Hybrid, against 38 for the 2020 to 2022 CR-V Hybrid and 40 front-drive or 37 AWD for the 2023 and newer. The RAV4 Prime adds 42 miles of electric range on 2021 to 2025 models.
Yes on both; the coverage follows the car from its first sale date, not from the day you buy it. Toyota covers the battery on 2020 and newer RAV4 Hybrids and Primes for 10 years or 150,000 miles for every owner, and 2016 to 2019 RAV4 Hybrids for 8 years or 100,000 miles, with other hybrid parts at 8 years/100,000 on every year. Honda’s national battery term on the CR-V Hybrid is 8 years or 100,000 miles; have a Honda dealer confirm the term on the VIN. ToyotaCare’s no-cost maintenance comes only with a new Toyota, so on a used car don’t count on it. Ask either dealer for a battery health report before you buy.
Both are available with AWD on every trim and every year covered here, and both do well on a plowed road with good tires. The RAV4 has the deeper bench: every RAV4 Hybrid since 2016 is AWD, the 2019 and newer Adventure, TRD Off-Road and AWD Limited use a torque-vectoring system that sends up to 50 percent of the torque to the rear, and the TRD Off-Road came on severe-snow-rated all-terrain tires. The CR-V’s Real Time AWD is an on-demand system that engages when the front wheels slip, and it is standard on the 2020 to 2022 CR-V Hybrid but a $1,500 option on most 2023 and newer trims. Think twice about a front-drive gas version of either if your driveway is steep or your street is plowed late; a front-drive car on four real winter tires still beats an AWD one on worn all-seasons.
The CR-V. A 2017 to 2022 CR-V has 39.2 cubic feet of cargo space behind the rear seat and 75.8 with it folded, with 40.4 inches of rear legroom; a 2023 and newer has 39.3 and 76.5 cubic feet and 41.0 inches. A 2019 to 2025 RAV4 has 37.6 cubic feet behind the seat and 37.8 inches of rear legroom; a 2013 to 2018 RAV4 has 38.4 cubic feet. The one exception is the 2020 to 2022 CR-V Hybrid, whose battery takes cargo space down to 33.2 cubic feet, while the RAV4 Hybrid keeps the full 37.6. Both seat five.
Gale Toyota buys both outright, in Enfield, minutes from Hartford and Springfield, with no obligation to buy a car from us; RAV4s and CR-Vs are the two most in-demand used SUVs we see. Bring the title or payoff information, every key, and your service records, and we will make a written offer the same visit. Start at galetoyota.com/sell-trade or with our used-car buying operation, The Buy Center of Enfield. We put every used car through the shop before it reaches the front line and do the work needed.
It is close, and the data splits. Kelley Blue Book named the CR-V its 2026 Best Resale Value compact SUV (March 2026), while Toyota won the 2026 brand award and iSeeCars’ March 2026 study put the RAV4, including the hybrid, seventh-lowest of all vehicles for five-year depreciation at 25.2 percent against a 41.8 percent industry average, with the CR-V outside the top ten. For a used buyer that means both keep value well above average, a same-year RAV4 usually costs a little more today, and either should resell well with records and an inspection.
Why Buy Here
Family-owned in Enfield, CT since 1969. Three generations. One promise: We’ve Got You.
01
When we install a part — brakes, battery, alternator, or more — we back it with a lifetime warranty on that part and the labor to reinstall it. You pay once. That’s it.
02
Three generations of the same family at 50 Palomba Drive in Enfield. We’re your neighbors — and we’ll still be here to service what we sell you.
03
Right on the Massachusetts border — convenient for buyers from Springfield, Agawam, Longmeadow, and all of northern Connecticut. Most customers are within 30 minutes.
Hybrids with AWD standard, gas models with the eight-speed, and Adventure and TRD Off-Road trims when we have them. We put every used car through the shop before it reaches the front line and do the work needed. Drive one in Enfield, minutes from Springfield, MA and Hartford, CT, and bring your CR-V or RAV4 if you have one to sell: we buy both outright, with no obligation to buy from us.