Sales (860) 741-3761
|
Loading...
|
Service (860) 253-3363
Loading...
|
Parts (860) 253-3362
Loading...
(860) 741-3761 Loading...
Sales
Service

2026 Three-Row Midsize SUV Comparison

2026 Toyota Highlander vs Honda Pilot

The 2026 Highlander is all-wheel drive on every trim and offers a 35-mpg hybrid. The Pilot is a V6-only SUV with a bigger third row and more cargo space. Here’s how they compare for Connecticut and Western Massachusetts families.

Our Pick

Toyota

2026 Highlander

From $46,270

AWD standard · 265-hp turbo or 243-hp hybrid · up to 35 mpg

VS

Honda

2026 Pilot

From $42,395

285-hp V6 only · 22 mpg FWD / 21 mpg AWD · 8 seats standard

2026 Toyota Highlander at Gale Toyota in Enfield, CT
The 2026 Toyota Highlander — all-wheel drive on every trim, a 265-hp turbo or a 243-hp hybrid rated 35 mpg, and the last model year planned with a gas or hybrid engine.
Our Pick: 2026 Highlander

The Bottom Line

For most families near Hartford and Springfield, the 2026 Highlander is the better buy: all-wheel drive is standard on every trim, the gas turbo is rated 24 mpg combined against 21 for an AWD Pilot, and the Highlander Hybrid returns 35 mpg, which no Pilot can approach. It is also the last of its kind: Toyota has said the gas and hybrid Highlander ends after 2026, with production extended through December, so this is the one to buy if you want one with an engine. The Pilot answers with a lower starting price, a much bigger third row (32.5 versus 27.7 inches of legroom), more cargo space and eight seats standard. If adults will ride in the back row often, cross-shop the Pilot. If fuel cost, standard AWD and a hybrid matter more, the Highlander wins.

It is also the better long-term bet on paper: Toyota is Kelley Blue Book’s 2026 Best Resale Value Brand and first in Consumer Reports’ latest brand reliability ranking, with Honda fourth.

Where the 2026 Highlander wins

  • Fuel Economy
  • Capability & Winter Driving
  • Warranty & Ownership
  • Reliability & Resale
4:2

Categories won

Where the 2026 Pilot wins

  • Value at the Base Price
  • Space & Practicality

Too close to call: Technology & Safety

Head-to-Head

2026 Highlander vs Pilot — Full Comparison

Specification 2026 Highlander 2026 Pilot Winner
Starting MSRP (before destination) $46,270 (XLE, AWD standard) $42,395 (Sport FWD); about $44,495 with AWD Pilot
Standard Powertrain 2.4L turbo 4-cyl, 8-speed automatic 3.5L V6, 10-speed automatic Tie
Horsepower / Torque 265 hp / 310 lb-ft 285 hp / 262 lb-ft Tie
Available Hybrid Yes: 2.5L hybrid, 243 hp, 35 mpg combined Not offered Highlander
MPG Combined (base) 24 mpg (gas, AWD) 22 mpg (FWD) / 21 mpg (AWD) Highlander
MPG Combined (best available) 35 mpg (Hybrid, AWD) 22 mpg (FWD) Highlander
Drivetrain AWD standard, every trim FWD standard; AWD about $2,100 on Sport and EX-L, standard on TrailSport and up Highlander
Max Towing 5,000 lb (gas); 3,500 lb (hybrid) 5,000 lb (AWD); 3,500 lb (FWD) Tie
Cargo Behind 3rd Row / Max 16.0 / 84.3 cu ft 18.6 / 87.0 cu ft Pilot
Third-Row Legroom 27.7 in 32.5 in Pilot
Seating 7 standard; 8 available on XLE and gas Limited 8 standard (7 on TrailSport) Pilot
Standard Driver-Assist Suite Toyota Safety Sense 2.5+ plus Blind Spot Monitor Honda Sensing plus Blind Spot Information Tie
Infotainment Screen (base) 8.0-in (12.3-in is a $735 option; standard on Limited and up) 12.3-in, every trim Pilot
Basic Warranty 3 yr / 36,000 mi 3 yr / 36,000 mi Tie
Powertrain Warranty 5 yr / 60,000 mi 5 yr / 60,000 mi Tie
Hybrid Battery Warranty 10 yr / 150,000 mi No hybrid offered Highlander
Included Maintenance ToyotaCare: 2 yr / 25,000 mi on 2026 model-year vehicles Honda Service Pass: 1 yr / 12,000 mi on 2025 and newer models Highlander
IIHS / NHTSA IIHS Good small overlap, Marginal updated moderate overlap, Good side; NHTSA 5-star overall IIHS Good small overlap, Acceptable updated moderate overlap, Good side; NHTSA 5-star overall (2025 rating; 2026 not yet listed) Pilot
Resale Value (KBB 2026 Best Resale Value Awards) Toyota is the 2026 Best Resale Value Brand (about 53% of sticker kept at 5 years; industry about 45%) No brand or segment award for 2026 Highlander
Brand Reliability (Consumer Reports, Dec 2025) Toyota 1st, score 66 Honda 4th, score 59 Highlander
Chance of Reaching 250,000 Miles (iSeeCars, Sept 2026) Highlander Hybrid 20.7%; gas Highlander 12.3% (average 5.3%) Pilot 14.3% Highlander
Hybrid Track Record Toyota hybrids since 1997, about 30 million sold worldwide through 2025; Highlander Hybrid since 2006 No Pilot hybrid; Honda’s current two-motor hybrid dates to 2014 Highlander

Specs and pricing reflect 2026 model-year manufacturer and EPA figures checked in November 2026 and may vary by trim, configuration and driving conditions. Competitor figures are shown for comparison and are subject to change; confirm current details with the manufacturer. MSRPs shown are before destination, tax, title and registration. Gale’s advertised prices include the $649 documentation fee. Contact Gale Toyota for current pricing and availability.

Category by Category

Where Each One Wins

Fuel Economy

Winner: Highlander

This is the Highlander’s biggest advantage. Its 2.4-liter turbo is rated 24 mpg combined with standard AWD; an AWD Pilot is rated 21 and a front-drive Pilot 22. The Highlander Hybrid is rated 35 mpg, and the Pilot has no hybrid at all. For a family driving 15,000 miles a year between Enfield, Hartford and Springfield, the hybrid uses roughly 430 gallons a year against about 715 for an AWD Pilot, a difference of about 285 gallons every year.

Value at the Base Price

Winner: Pilot

The Pilot Sport starts at $42,395 before destination, about $3,875 under the Highlander XLE, and it includes a 12.3-inch touchscreen, eight seats, a power tailgate and roof rails. Add AWD and the gap narrows to about $1,775. The Highlander XLE counters with standard AWD, a power moonroof, heated SofTex seats, a hands-free liftgate and better mileage, so it is the better-equipped vehicle, but on the sticker the Pilot costs less.

Space & Practicality

Winner: Pilot

The Pilot is about 5 inches longer and 2.5 inches wider, and it shows in the back. Third-row legroom is 32.5 inches against the Highlander’s 27.7, second-row legroom is 40.8 against 38.7, and cargo space is 18.6 cubic feet behind the third row against 16.0, with 87.0 cubic feet maximum against 84.3. Eight seats are standard on most Pilots; the Highlander seats seven unless you choose the no-cost bench on the XLE or gas Limited. For more third-row room in a Toyota, see the Grand Highlander.

Capability & Winter Driving

Winner: Highlander

Every 2026 Highlander is AWD, with 8.0 inches of ground clearance and 310 lb-ft of torque from 1,700 rpm. The Pilot Sport and EX-L are front-wheel drive unless you pay about $2,100 for AWD, and most trims sit at 7.3 inches. Towing is a wash: 5,000 pounds for the gas Highlander and the AWD Pilot, 3,500 for the Highlander Hybrid and the FWD Pilot. The Pilot TrailSport, with 8.3 inches of clearance and all-terrain tires, is the one Pilot built for unplowed roads.

Technology & Safety

Winner: Too Close to Call

Every Pilot gets a 12.3-inch touchscreen, a 10.2-inch digital cluster and Google built-in; the Highlander XLE and XSE have an 8.0-inch screen with the 12.3-inch unit a $735 option. Both have a full driver-assist suite and blind-spot monitoring standard, and both carry a five-star NHTSA overall rating. In IIHS testing the Pilot scores a notch higher in the updated moderate overlap test; the Highlander Platinum answers with a head-up display, 360-degree camera and adaptive headlights that IIHS rates Good.

Warranty & Ownership

Winner: Highlander

The basic terms match: 3 years/36,000 miles bumper to bumper, 5 years/60,000 miles on the powertrain and 5 years of corrosion coverage from both brands. ToyotaCare covers 2 years/25,000 miles of scheduled maintenance on 2026 model-year vehicles; Honda Service Pass covers 1 year/12,000 miles of select services on 2025 and newer models. The Highlander pulls ahead on the hybrid: Toyota backs the battery for 10 years/150,000 miles, and the fuel savings above continue for as long as you own it.

Reliability & Resale

Winner: Highlander

Kelley Blue Book’s 2026 Best Resale Value Awards (March 2026) named Toyota the Best Resale Value Brand, projecting about 53 percent of sticker retained after five years against an industry average near 45; Honda did not take the brand award, and neither of these two won its segment (the Toyota Grand Highlander did). Consumer Reports’ survey published in December 2025 ranks Toyota first for brand reliability with a score of 66 and Honda fourth at 59, and notes that conventional hybrids keep scoring well. In iSeeCars’ September 2026 study of vehicles reaching 250,000 miles, the Highlander Hybrid rated 20.7 percent, the Pilot 14.3 and the gas Highlander 12.3, all against a 5.3 percent average. The hybrid is the clincher: Toyota has built hybrids since the 1997 Prius and had sold about 30 million worldwide through 2025, and the Highlander Hybrid has been sold since 2006; the Pilot has no hybrid.

Common Questions

Highlander vs Pilot FAQ

Is the Honda Pilot bigger than the Toyota Highlander?

Yes. The 2026 Pilot is 200.1 inches long and 78.5 inches wide against 194.9 and 76.0 for the Highlander, and the extra size goes to the back: 32.5 inches of third-row legroom versus 27.7, and 18.6 cubic feet of cargo behind the third row versus 16.0 (87.0 versus 84.3 cubic feet with the rear seats folded). The Pilot also seats eight on most trims; the Highlander seats seven unless you choose the no-cost second-row bench on the XLE or gas Limited. The Highlander is the easier one to park and fits a standard garage with room to spare.

Which gets better gas mileage, the Highlander or the Pilot?

The Highlander, by a wide margin. The gas Highlander is rated 24 mpg combined with its standard AWD, while the Pilot’s V6 is rated 22 mpg with front-wheel drive and 21 with AWD. The Highlander Hybrid is rated 35 mpg combined, and Honda does not offer a Pilot hybrid. At 15,000 miles a year the hybrid uses roughly 430 gallons against about 715 for an AWD Pilot, and both SUVs run on regular unleaded.

Is the Highlander or the Pilot cheaper?

The Pilot starts lower. The 2026 Pilot Sport is $42,395 before destination with front-wheel drive, about $3,875 under the Highlander XLE at $46,270, which comes with AWD standard. Add AWD to the Pilot Sport and it is about $44,495, so the gap shrinks to roughly $1,775. The Highlander Hybrid XLE is $48,020, and no Pilot can match its 35 mpg at any price. Both figures are manufacturer MSRPs before destination; current Gale pricing is on each Highlander vehicle page.

Does the Highlander have a hybrid? Does the Pilot?

The Highlander does and the Pilot does not. The 2026 Highlander Hybrid pairs a 2.5-liter engine with electric motors for 243 hp, AWD and an EPA-estimated 35 mpg combined, and it costs $1,750 more than the gas engine on the XLE, Limited and Platinum. Every 2026 Pilot uses the same 285-hp 3.5-liter V6 with a 10-speed automatic; Honda has not offered a Pilot hybrid. Toyota backs the Highlander’s hybrid battery for 10 years or 150,000 miles, and the battery sits inside the heated cabin rather than under the cargo floor, which helps in a Connecticut winter.

Which is better in snow, the Highlander or the Pilot?

Both handle a New England winter well once they have AWD, but only the Highlander includes it: every 2026 Highlander is AWD, with 8.0 inches of ground clearance and a snow setting in Multi-Terrain Select on the XSE, Limited and Platinum. The Pilot Sport and EX-L are front-wheel drive unless you add Honda’s i-VTM4 AWD for about $2,100; it is standard on the TrailSport, Touring, Elite and Black Edition and includes a Snow mode. The Pilot TrailSport, with 8.3 inches of clearance and all-terrain tires, is the one Pilot with more clearance than the Highlander. On either SUV, a set of winter tires matters more than the badge.

Which tows more, the Highlander or the Pilot?

They match. The gas Highlander is rated at 5,000 pounds on every trim, and so is every AWD Pilot. The Highlander Hybrid is rated at 3,500 pounds, the same as a front-wheel-drive Pilot. The Highlander’s turbo makes 310 lb-ft of torque at 1,700 rpm against the Pilot’s 262 lb-ft at 5,000 rpm, which helps when pulling a trailer away from a stop; neither is a travel-trailer tow vehicle, and for that Toyota offers the Sequoia at up to 9,010 pounds.

Which has a better warranty, Toyota or Honda?

On paper they are the same: 3 years/36,000 miles bumper to bumper, 5 years/60,000 miles on the powertrain and 5 years of corrosion coverage with no mileage limit from both brands. ToyotaCare covers scheduled maintenance for 2 years/25,000 miles on 2026 model-year vehicles; Honda Service Pass covers 1 year/12,000 miles on 2025 and newer models. The difference is the hybrid: Toyota covers the Highlander Hybrid’s battery for 10 years/150,000 miles and other hybrid components for 8 years/100,000 miles, and the Pilot has no hybrid to cover.

Highlander vs Pilot: which should I buy?

Buy the Highlander if you want AWD included, the best fuel economy in the class (35 mpg with the hybrid) and a smaller footprint, and because 2026 is the last model year Toyota plans to sell a gas or hybrid Highlander. Buy the Pilot if adults or teenagers will ride in the third row regularly, you need eight seats and the most cargo room, or you want the lowest starting price and a V6. If you like the Toyota side but need the Pilot’s space, the Grand Highlander offers 33.5 inches of third-row legroom with the same engines plus the Hybrid MAX.

Which holds its value better, the Highlander or the Pilot?

On the latest data, the Toyota. Kelley Blue Book named Toyota its 2026 Best Resale Value Brand in March 2026, projecting about 53 percent of sticker retained after five years against an industry average near 45 percent; Honda did not win the brand award, and neither the Highlander nor the Pilot won its segment (the Toyota Grand Highlander did). Resale on any one vehicle depends on trim, mileage and condition, so treat these as averages rather than a promise.

Why Buy Here

Why Gale Toyota

Family-owned in Enfield, CT since 1969. Three generations. One promise: We’ve Got You.

01

One & Done Warranty

When we install a part — brakes, battery, alternator, or more — we back it with a lifetime warranty on that part and the labor to reinstall it. You pay once. That’s it.

02

Family-Owned Since 1969

Three generations of the same family at 50 Palomba Drive in Enfield. We’re your neighbors — and we’ll still be here to service what we sell you.

03

Serving CT & MA

Right on the Massachusetts border — convenient for buyers from Springfield, Agawam, Longmeadow, and all of northern Connecticut. Most customers are within 30 minutes.

See the 2026 Highlander at Gale Toyota

AWD on every trim, a 35-mpg hybrid, and the last model year with a gas or hybrid engine. Drive it in Enfield — minutes from Springfield, MA and Hartford, CT.